“Sometimes the villain isn’t the first person to create the problem. Sometimes she’s simply the first one willing to acknowledge it.”
Disney has given us some of the most memorable villains in cinematic history. They are larger than life, deliciously theatrical, and impossible to forget. Yet beneath the songs, the sarcasm, and the sinister laughter, many of them challenge something that deserves questioning.
Few do this better than Ursula.
Let’s be clear from the beginning: Ursula is manipulative. She deceives Ariel, twists contracts to her advantage, and ultimately seeks power over the kingdom. She is not the hero of the story.
But that doesn’t mean she was wrong about everything.
In fact, Ursula is the first character in The Little Mermaid who truly sees Ariel.
Before Ursula enters the story, Ariel is treated less like a young woman discovering who she is and more like a daughter whose future has already been decided. She is fascinated by the human world, curious about life beyond the sea, and desperate to make choices for herself. Instead of asking why his daughter feels this way, King Triton responds with anger. He dismisses her dreams as foolish. He destroys the collection of human artifacts that brings her joy. He believes that authority is enough to settle the matter.
Many of us recognize that dynamic.
Parents often believe they are protecting their children when they are really protecting their own expectations. Love becomes intertwined with control. “I know what’s best for you” replaces “Help me understand who you are.”
King Triton is not a cruel father. He loves Ariel deeply.
But love without listening can still become a cage.
That is the injustice Ursula recognizes.
When Ariel arrives at Ursula’s lair, Ursula doesn’t have to convince her that something is wrong. Ariel already knows. Ursula simply names the longing that no one else has taken seriously.
“You want more.”
For the first time in the film, someone acknowledges Ariel’s desire instead of dismissing it.
That moment matters.
Of course, Ursula exploits Ariel’s vulnerability. She offers freedom with hidden conditions, disguising manipulation as liberation. Her contract is intentionally deceptive. She never intends for Ariel to succeed.
That is where Ursula becomes the villain.
But recognizing someone’s pain and exploiting it are not the same thing.
The pain was real long before Ursula arrived.
Watching The Little Mermaid as children, many of us saw Ariel as an impulsive teenager making reckless decisions.
Watching it as adults, we see something more complicated.
We see a young woman trying to become herself in a family that mistakes obedience for faithfulness.
That tension feels remarkably familiar to many LGBTQ+ people.
For generations, queer people have heard versions of the same message Ariel receives:
“You don’t know what’s best for yourself.”
“This is just a phase.”
“You’ll understand when you’re older.”
“We’re only trying to protect you.”
Most parents who say these things genuinely love their children. Like Triton, they believe they are preventing harm.
But good intentions cannot erase the experience of not being heard.
Many LGBTQ+ adults describe coming out not as choosing a new identity but as finally having words for the person they had always been. The deepest wound often isn’t rejection itself. It’s spending years feeling that the people who loved them most never truly saw them.
That is why Ursula continues to resonate.
Not because she is morally admirable.
But because she recognizes Ariel’s longing before anyone else does.
There is another layer to Ursula that makes her especially compelling. The animators famously drew inspiration from the legendary drag performer Divine. Without ever saying so explicitly, Disney created one of its most unforgettable villains using the aesthetic of queer performance. Like many villains of her era, Ursula was coded as an outsider—someone extravagant, unconventional, and impossible to ignore.
Ironically, many queer viewers found themselves identifying with her, not because they admired her schemes, but because they recognized what it feels like to live outside the accepted norms of society.
She occupied the margins.
She understood exclusion.
She recognized longing.
Those experiences are not inherently villainous.
In the decades since The Little Mermaid was released, conversations about parenting have evolved. We increasingly understand that healthy families are built not merely on authority but on curiosity. Good parents ask questions. They make room for conversations they do not fully understand. They recognize that guiding a child is different from controlling one.
King Triton eventually learns that lesson.
Only after nearly losing Ariel does he realize that loving his daughter means trusting her enough to let her choose her own life.
That transformation—not Ursula’s defeat—is the emotional climax of the film.
The story ends not because evil has been vanquished but because a father finally begins to see his daughter as she truly is.
Perhaps that is Ursula’s greatest contribution to the story.
She exposes the conflict that everyone else is trying to ignore.
She reminds us that people rarely seek impossible bargains when they already feel safe, understood, and free.
If Ariel had been heard from the beginning, there would have been no reason to visit Ursula’s cave.
The villain did not create Ariel’s longing.
She merely recognized it.
And perhaps that is why Ursula remains one of Disney’s greatest antagonists. Not because she was right to manipulate a vulnerable young woman, but because she correctly identified the problem that love alone could not solve.
Sometimes the most dangerous prison isn’t built from stone.
Sometimes it’s built from someone else’s expectations.
And sometimes the first person to point at the bars is wearing tentacles.
Leave a Reply